Are you an Independent Medical Examiner (IME) or Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME)? Then, this article is for you. Becoming a respected IME or QME is about more than just passing an exam or obtaining the necessary credentials. Your reputation is built over time through how professional and objective you are in your evaluation and reporting. Trust is the foundation of your successful practice. Injured workers, legal representatives, and claims administrators, all rely on your expertise to provide a fair and accurate assessment.
However, most of the examinees approach these kinds of evaluations with anxiety, uncertainty, or skepticism. They fear that your evaluation may be biased or predetermined, affecting their claim or benefits. Your ability to build trust can improve patient’s cooperation as well as help you provide accurate assessments. But how to build trust while maintaining objectivity? The way you conduct yourself during the evaluation, such as the way you communicate, assess, and document your findings, can help you building trust in IME/QME evaluations.
Through this blog, we delve into the factors that help you build a reputable IME/QME practice.
How to Become a Trusted IME/QME in Demand
Your credibility starts with a strategic approach focusing on professionalism, transparency, and objectivity. Let’s see them in detail:
1. A friendly and approachable presence
As you have heard, first impression is the best impression. Whether you are performing an IME for a disability claim, or a QME for a worker’s compensation case, the first impression you create on the examinees matter a lot. Right from the moment they enter your office, until you start your evaluation, they form their opinion on you.
Many examinees feel that the evaluation process is impersonal or unsympathetic, especially if they are unfamiliar with how these assessments work. Moreover, a lot of articles in the internet portray you as villains/adversaries to be cautious of. So, how to handle this situation and build trust?
Warm introduction: Starting with a professional introduction of who you are and why the evaluation process is done in a warm tone can set the stage for you. Instead of delving into the examination directly, take a moment to explain your role, like in the below example:
“ Hello, I’m Dr. (Name). I am an independent medical evaluator. My role is to assess your condition and provide an objective medical opinion. I know this process can feel stressful, so I’ll guide you through each step to ensure we have a clear and fair evaluation.”
This kind of approach can be helpful in both IME and QME evaluations. In QME evaluations, injured workers may already feel defensive and distrustful due to their ongoing legal disputes. Whereas, in IME evaluations, the examinees may be worried if their disability benefits or employment status get affected by your report. A calm and respectful approach reassures them that they will be treated fairly.
Body language: Beyond your tone and introduction, your body language matters. Make an eye contact, maintain a calm and neutral tone and show genuine attentiveness to get a sense of respect from the examinee. Avoid interrupting when they share their concerns and acknowledge their experience by noting down the details. Ask follow-up questions to show that you are listening carefully.
Approach of the administrative staff: Apart from how you approach the examinee, your office environment and staff also play an important role in establishing trust. If your front desk staff is unfriendly and unorganized, it creates a negative first impression even before the evaluation starts. If an outside management company handles your administrative tasks, ensure that they have a professional at the same time sympathetic approach.
2. Communicate clearly and set expectations
Medical evaluations can be intimidating to someone unfamiliar with the process. If the injured workers, claimants or their legal representatives do not know the process, they will be anxious or frustrated of the exam. Explaining the process in simple terms can put them at ease. Instead of immediately starting the assessment, give a clear outline of the process as seen below:
“First, I’ll review your medical history and ask some questions to understand your symptoms. Then, I’ll perform a physical exam to assess your movement and function. If anything feels uncomfortable, please let me know. My goal is to gather all the necessary information to make an objective assessment.”
Let them know that you are only a medical evaluator and not a treating physician. Your role as an IME/QME is to assess the medical condition and form medical opinions, and not to provide treatment recommendations.
Avoid complex medical jargon when explaining medical conditions or findings. Instead of saying:
“I’ll be performing an orthopedic assessment to evaluate functional capacity.”-
Say: “I’m going to check how well your joints move and how strong your muscles are to better understand how your injury affects your daily activities.”
When you explain them in simple language and encourage communication, you can reduce their stress and get proper cooperation with your exam.
Asking clarifications is another way to build trust. If you ask, “Where does it hurt?,” you may not get an accurate response. Instead, if you ask, “ Can you describe the pain when you bend your knee? Does it get worse with movement or remain constant?” prompt them to provide detailed answers. If the examinees feel their symptoms are being taken seriously, they will trust you and your examination. This can make your evaluation more effective.
3. Conduct a thorough and well-documented examination
An IME or QME evaluation must be thorough, impartial and well-documented. Examinees, attorney, and claim administrator rely on your findings. So, when you conduct a rushed and incomplete exam, it may lead to disputed results and increased depositions. Moreover, if the examinees sense that the evaluation is not thorough, they may think the evaluation is unfair. If a QME evaluation seemed to be unfair, they request for a new panel, damaging your reputation.
To ensure a comprehensive and objective evaluation, do the following:
- Review all medical records early to have a clear understanding of the patient’s history before they arrive.
- Perform a detailed physical examination that aligns with the patient’s symptoms and reported limitations.
- Conduct functional assessments, if the examinee’s ability to perform daily activities is in question.
- Remain neutral and evidence-based to avoid any assumptions about exaggeration of symptoms or motivation.
When you ensure your findings are consistent with the evaluation, it will increase the trust on you. For example, if the IME report suggests that a patient’s symptoms are minimal, the physical evaluation should have proof for that. An incomplete physical evaluation can even cast a dubious cloud over the credibility of your evaluation. Similarly, if the conclusions in a QME report contradict medical records without proper explanation, claim adjusters and attorneys will dispute your findings.
4. Deliver accurate, objective reports
Building trust doesn’t end with the exam, it extends into how the findings are presented in the report. A well-documented IME/QME report should be free of assumptions and evidence-based. It should be detailed, structured and neutral.
Key principles for effective IME/QME reporting include:
- Stick to facts: Avoid subjective statements or opinions outside of your expertise. Differentiate between the subjective complaints and objective findings like in the below example: Patient’s complaint: Patient reports persistent shoulder pain that prevents him from performing overhead activities. Doctor’s objective finding: Patient exhibits limited shoulder mobility with pain reported at 70 degrees of flexion. No observable swelling or bruising was present.
- Be consistent: Your conclusions should align with both the physical examination and the medical records. Clearly explain discrepancies if noted any.
- Use clear, simple language: Both medical and non-medical professionals like attorneys, claim adjusters, and judges will read the IME/QME report. Avoid unnecessary medical jargon to keep your report simple enough to understand.
- Be neutral and ethical: Your role is to provide an objective medical evaluation, and not to determine if the patient’s claim should be accepted. Set clear boundaries regarding this.
- Be transparent about conflicts of interest: If you have treated the patient before or have worked with a referring attorney, mention it upfront to avoid concerns about bias.
By consistently producing neutral, high-quality reports, you can strengthen your reputation and reduce the likelihood of frequent depositions, challenges, or disputes.
5. Build trust outside the evaluation room
Don’t think that building trust can only be done in the examination room. It goes beyond the exam room and into the way how you interact with the other professionals involved in the case. Your interactions with attorneys, claim administrators and treating physicians of the claimants can influence how they perceive your evaluations.
You can build trust throughout the process in the following ways:
- Professional communication: Respond to the inquiries from attorneys and claim administrators promptly and professionally. If they request clarification on your report, address it thoroughly while staying neutral. Your willingness to provide reasonable explanations reassure them that your assessments are well-prepared.
- Stay updated on the medical-legal standards: Be well-versed in worker’s compensation and disability regulations. It ensures that your evaluations align with industry standards. When legal and claim professionals see that your reports follow current medical-legal guidelines, they may trust your evaluation and expertise.
- Participate in industry conferences: Attend industry-related conferences, seminars, events and networking platforms hosted by organizations, such as the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA) or state workers’ compensation groups. It can help you stay up-to-date on evolving practices and improve the quality of your evaluations and create trust in your practice.
- Known for fairness and objectivity: Develop a reputation for fairness, thoroughness, and neutrality. It will speak your name among the attorneys and claim administrators. This can benefit both your credibility and the trust examinees place in your evaluation.
To put in a nutshell,
Building trust during medical evaluations doesn’t mean supporting the claimant. It means ensuring they feel heard, respected and fairly assessed. Trust can be built through consistent professionalism, clear communication, thorough evaluations and unbiased reports. A patient-centered approach, combined with detailed and evidence-based assessments, will set you apart as a respected and in-demand medical evaluator.
See Our Success Stories – Dive Into Our Case Studies.
